01Chickie's & Pete's
Chickie’s & Pete’s is a quintessential Philadelphia establishment. Founded in the Northeast almost 50 years ago, this neighborhood bar now has outposts in stadiums, ai…
OVERALL6.96
ROLL 5.0MEAT 7.9CHEESE 6.3ONIONS 8.7
SEEDED ROLLCHEESESTEAKS. REVIEWED.01
THE FIELD NOTES
REVIEWS.
Independent Seeded Roll cheesesteak reviews, scored consistently and presented without blending in community ratings.
ALL PUBLISHED
32FROM THE NOTEBOOK
01
02Seasons Pizza
I first had Season’s Pizza in Newark just off the campus of the University of Delaware. It seemed to me that it was the chain pizza place you go to if you don’t like G…
OVERALL6.23
ROLL 5.3MEAT 7.0CHEESE 6.0ONIONS 6.7
03The Kibitz Room
The Kibitz Room is one of Cherry Hill’s last standing neighborhood Jewish delis. You come here for the pastrami, pickle bar, the mile-high Ruebens, the knishes, and mo…
OVERALL7.95
ROLL 8.3MEAT 8.2CHEESE 8.0CONCEPT 7.3
04Dooney’s Pub
Dooney’s has been around for quite awhile but we never tried it until recently. Everything has been great on our trips there, so we decided to try their cheesesteaks f…
OVERALL6.33
ROLL 6.0MEAT 7.0CHEESE 6.0ONIONS 6.3
05Please Touch Museum
Hi neighbor! Okay, I know, no one goes to a museum to try the cheesesteak. But since I was here, why not try it? It’s been decades since I have been to the Please Touc…
OVERALL4.64
ROLL 4.5MEAT 5.4CHEESE 4.0ONIONS N/A
06Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria
Peppino’s is the new kid on the block when it comes to South Jersey cheesesteaks. (This is the former location of Organico, one of Marlton’s better known pizzerias.) A…
OVERALL8.54
ROLL 9.0MEAT 8.1CHEESE 9.0ONIONS 8.0
07Virtua Voorhees Hospital
Virtua Health’s Voorhees Hospital received recent acclaim for their cafeteria. Word had apparently spread in Facebook groups and on the local news about the surprising…
OVERALL5.25
ROLL 4.8MEAT 6.0CHEESE 5.0ONIONS N/A
08Wawa
Wawa is a Philly thing. Cheesesteaks are a Philly thing. This should be the perfect combination. Wawa has come a long way in its 60 year history, and seems to be alway…
OVERALL5.42
ROLL 3.5MEAT 5.9CHEESE 4.7ONIONS 7.7
09Passariello's Pizzeria
We love Passariello’s. I have been enjoying pasta, Stromboli, and pizza from their South Jersey locations as long as I can remember. So I had to try their cheesesteak.…
OVERALL7.21
ROLL 5.5MEAT 8.0CHEESE 6.3ONIONS 9.0
10Foodie Hall
A few months ago this was branded as Geno’s, which was one of several food concepts working out of what seems to be a shared kitchen space called Foodie Hall. The faci…
OVERALL7.35
ROLL 6.3MEAT 7.1CHEESE 7.7ONIONS 8.3
11Raceway Bagels
This was another very strongly hyped cheesesteak and breakfast sandwich spot. It was either owned by or closely affiliated with B-Uno’s, a chain of 3 or so Mexican res…
OVERALL5.01
ROLL 4.3MEAT 6.1CHEESE 5.3ONIONS 4.3
12PJ Whelihan's
One roll option-non seeded. One cheese option-American. Small sandwich, cheese mixed in, meat quantity not great. Onions sizes and flavor are good snd well mixed. Chop…
OVERALL7.50
ROLL 5.8MEAT 8.6CHEESE 6.7ONIONS 9.0
13Berardi Brothers Pizza
Berardi Brothers is often acclaimed as the best cheesesteak down the Shore (Sea Isle City), but they also have a location in Southampton, PA. This family runs deep in…
OVERALL8.56
ROLL 7.5MEAT 8.9CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
14Stoli’s Steaks
From Cafe Carmela, we went further north on Bustleton Avenue to Stoli’s Steaks in Somerton. This is so far north, you’re not even sure if it’s still Philly (it is). Th…
OVERALL7.10
ROLL 8.5MEAT 5.1CHEESE 7.7ONIONS N/A
15Café Carmela
The wait at each of the PA places is insane. 30-45 min for a cheesesteak. They asked for a 30% tip… really good. Nice bread (non seeded roll). Good meat and cheese tas…
OVERALL8.69
ROLL 8.5MEAT 8.6CHEESE 9.0ONIONS N/A
16Angelo's Pizzeria South Philly
Angelo’s has been by far the biggest name in the Cheesesteak 2.0 movement on the Pennsylvania side of the river. This shop opened on 9th and Fitzwater in 2019, but had…
OVERALL8.50
ROLL 8.8MEAT 7.4CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
17John's Roast Pork
John’s has been serving up their famous namesake Italian-style roast pork sandwich on the corner of Snyder and Weccacoe Avenues since the 1930’s. While the majority of…
OVERALL7.38
ROLL 7.3MEAT 7.3CHEESE 8.0ONIONS 7.0
18Yard House
This is a cool place. I used to come here a lot when traveling for work. The 100+ draft beers and huge food menu draw you in, but the food is actually really good. The…
OVERALL5.36
ROLL 5.5MEAT 6.3CHEESE 6.3ONIONS 3.3
19Geno’s Steaks
Note: This location has since closed. That’s right. It’s that Geno’s. Straight from East Passyunk to an industrial park in Cherry Hill, NJ. This is one of several food…
OVERALL5.78
ROLL 4.5MEAT 6.3CHEESE 6.0ONIONS 6.3
20Mama’s Meatballs & Pizzeria
The official review was actually my second trip here. I had a unique cheesesteak the first time, with long hots, broccoli rabe and a ton of olive oil, so to give this…
OVERALL6.23
ROLL 4.3MEAT 6.4CHEESE 8.0ONIONS N/A
21Brynn Bradley
Note: The restaurant has moved, and is now located in Woodbury Heights, NJ. This was a sandwich getting a lot of hype. It’s a small place that feels almost like a tiny…
OVERALL8.13
ROLL 8.5MEAT 6.6CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
22TJ's Family Pizza
This is one of those local pizza shops that has pictures on the menu from some sort of clip art (if it were built today, would they be A.I. generated). As a result, yo…
OVERALL6.13
ROLL 6.5MEAT 6.0CHEESE 5.0ONIONS 7.0
23Curly’s Comfort Food
This is definitely an old Checker’s. But while I don’t remember Checker’s being anything but drive thru, this does have a small inside area where you order and there a…
OVERALL7.83
ROLL 8.0MEAT 6.1CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
24Donkey’s Place Downtown
Oh boy. I’m not sure where to start. Anthony Bourdain called this his favorite cheesesteak. That was on a 2015 episode, so he was most likely comparing it against the…
OVERALL4.63
ROLL 4.8MEAT 5.1CHEESE 4.0ONIONS N/A
25Chicks Deli
Chick’s is another staple of Cherry Hill’s golden era (established two years before Lou & Ann’s, in 1957). Tucked away in a back alley behind some smoke shops, if you…
OVERALL7.46
ROLL 6.3MEAT 8.6CHEESE 7.0ONIONS 8.0
26Ponzio's
Diners are one of the most uniquely New Jersey institutions, and Ponzio’s is one of the best. The Ponzio’s name dates back to the mid-1960’s and has became a favorite…
OVERALL5.88
ROLL 7.8MEAT 7.6CHEESE 2.3ONIONS N/A
27Lou & Anne’s Delicatessen
Lou & Ann’s is a Cherry Hill legend. In fact, established in 1959, Lou & Ann’s pre-dates the naming of Cherry Hill Township (was the town really named after the Mall,…
OVERALL7.86
ROLL 9.3MEAT 6.9CHEESE 9.3ONIONS 6.0
28Gaetano’s
I remember Gaetano’s reputation as a leader in cheesesteaks from many years ago, but I never tried it before. They have a handful of locations throughout New Jersey an…
OVERALL4.18
ROLL 5.8MEAT 7.3CHEESE 1.7ONIONS 2.0
29Pat's Pizza and Grill
I remember eating Pat’s Pizza many years ago. It was a small chain of pizza and sandwich shops based in Salem County. Pat’s Select is a modern off-shoot with a strong…
OVERALL7.26
ROLL 9.3MEAT 8.1CHEESE 4.3ONIONS 7.3
30Corson’s Steaks
Corson’s is a small shop on one of Haddonfield’s side streets just off of King’s Highway. This was a fairly pricey cheesesteak, but as far as I could tell was one of t…
OVERALL5.62
ROLL 8.8MEAT 4.7CHEESE 5.3ONIONS 3.7
31Meatheadz Cheesesteaks
This was a little bit of a drive. We’re getting further from Philly…is this even cheesesteak territory anymore? There’s a pretty large menu, including specialty steaks…
OVERALL8.69
ROLL 8.8MEAT 9.0CHEESE 8.3ONIONS N/A
32Lillo’s Tomato Pies
I remember when Lillo’s first opened, their Trenton-style tomato pie was their signature dish. (And trust me, it’s worth it!) But in short time, word travelled that Li…
OVERALL8.86
ROLL 8.0MEAT 8.6CHEESE 10.0ONIONS N/A
