HAINESPORT, NJ
Lillo’s Tomato Pies
ROLL 8.0MEAT 8.6CHEESE 10.0ONIONS N/A
8.86OVERALL
SEEDED ROLLCHEESESTEAKS. REVIEWED.GUIDE
LIVE EDITORIAL GUIDE
BEST CHEESESTEAKS.
This living guide follows Seeded Roll’s current Traditional rankings. When a newly published Traditional review changes the order, this guide changes with it.
TRADITIONAL CHEESESTEAKS · UPDATED SEPTEMBER 15, 2026
10THE CURRENT TOP 10
This is an editorial ranking, not a sponsored list. Chicken and Specialty cheesesteaks have separate rankings and are not included here.
LAWRENCE TOWNSHIP, NEW JERSEY
Meatheadz Cheesesteaks
ROLL 8.8MEAT 9.0CHEESE 8.3ONIONS N/A
8.69OVERALL
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA
Café Carmela
ROLL 8.5MEAT 8.6CHEESE 9.0ONIONS N/A
8.69OVERALL
SOUTHAMPTON, PA
Berardi Brothers Pizza
ROLL 7.5MEAT 8.9CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
8.56OVERALL
MARLTON, NJ
Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria
ROLL 9.0MEAT 8.1CHEESE 9.0ONIONS 8.0
8.54OVERALL
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA
Angelo's Pizzeria South Philly
ROLL 8.8MEAT 7.4CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
8.50OVERALL
HADDONFIELD, NJ
Gouldsburger’s
ROLL 8.3MEAT 8.6CHEESE 9.0ONIONS 8.0
8.46OVERALL
WOODBURY HEIGHTS, NJ
Brynn Bradley
ROLL 8.5MEAT 6.6CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
8.13OVERALL
CHERRY HILL, NJ
Lou & Anne’s Delicatessen
ROLL 9.3MEAT 6.9CHEESE 9.3ONIONS 6.0
7.86OVERALL
LEVITTOWN, PA
Curly’s Comfort Food
ROLL 8.0MEAT 6.1CHEESE 9.3ONIONS N/A
7.83OVERALL
